SSI – Losing brokerage market share; strong earnings in Q1 2024 – Earnings Flash
  • 2024-05-03T00:00:00
  • Company Research

SSI released its consolidated results for Q1 2024 with net profit of VND764bn (USD31mn; +52% YoY), fulfilling 25% of our FY2024 forecast. Q1 2024 operating income (defined to include gains but not losses on the principal book) increased 32.5% YoY to VND2.0tn (USD79mn), completing 23% of our full-year forecast, with gains from FVTPL as the key growth driver, accounting for 46% of total operating income. We attribute this to SSI allocating 60% of its total assets to FVTPL assets, mainly certificates of deposits and bonds. Additionally, Q1 2024 operating expenses increased by 51.7% YoY – higher than the increase in operating income that resulted in a 3.8 ppts decrease in GPM (69.8% in Q1 2024). This is mainly due to a higher loss from FVTPL. Overall, SSI’s results were broadly in line with our expectations. We see no material changes to our earnings forecasts for SSI, pending a more extensive review.

  • Q1 2024 consolidated PBT from principal investment increased 28% YoY and 33% QoQ, accounting for 54.2% of SSI’s PBT. 
  • Q1 2024 gains from HTM investments (which include deposits and certificates of deposit with terms of less than one year) decreased 5.7% YoY and 7.5% QoQ amid a decrease in HTM balance and lower interest rate environment.
  • Q1 2024 brokerage revenue increased 74.9% YoY following a 2.0x YoY increase in Q1 2024 average daily trading value (ADTV) to USD962mn from USD484mn in Q1 2023. On a QoQ basis, Q1 2024 brokerage revenue increased by 20% QoQ. The commission rate was maintained at 0.18% over the past five quarters. However, we estimate that SSI lost market share on three trading venues combined in Q1 2024 to 8.8% from 9.0% in Q4 2023 and 10.8% in Q1 2023. SSI has recently launched a zero brokerage fees promotion for new customers for one year, which we believe will have a positive impact on SSI’s brokerage market share in the remainder of the year.
  • In Q1 2024, SSI’s margin lending book increased 58% YoY and 16% QoQ due to a lower interest rate environment and the positive movement of the market, which we believe could encourage customers to use more leverage.

SSI’s consolidated Q1 2024 results

VND bn

Q1 2023

Q1 2024

YoY

Operating income 

         1,489 

         1,973 

32.5%

Gains from FVTPL

            688 

            910 

32.3%

Gains from HTM 

            112 

            106 

-5.7%

Gains from AFS

                0.1 

                2 

2828.9%

Margin lending revenue 

            338 

            447 

32.0%

Brokerage revenue 

            257 

            449 

74.9%

Commission rate

                0.18% 

                0.18% 

1.0%

IB revenue 

              18 

                9 

-51.6%

Others 

              76 

              50 

-33.9%

Operating expenses 

            393 

            596 

51.7%

Loss from FVTPL

              73 

            167 

127.8%

Expenses for brokerage 

            252 

            348 

37.8%

Others 

              67 

              82 

21.5%

Gross operating profit 

         1,097 

         1,377 

25.5%

Financial income 

              19 

              40 

109.2%

Gains from affiliates/ divestments 

                9 

              22 

150.7%

Financial expenses 

            422 

            391 

-7.3%

Borrowing costs 

            392 

            383 

-2.3%

G&A expenses 

              77 

              83 

8.7%

Net other income 

                0.4 

                0.5 

12.7%

PBT

            618 

            943 

52.6%

NPAT 

            503 

            764 

52.0%

Margin lending book 

       11,118 

       17,570 

58.0%

GPM %

73.6%

69.8%

-3.8 ppts

NPM %

33.8%

38.7%

5.0 ppts

Source: SSI, Vietcap (units are in VND bn unless otherwise stated)

Powered by Froala Editor